My husband and I are packing up the car after a family stroll to the lighthouse at Robert Moses Beach, on the south shore of Long Island. I slide into the back seat beside my four-month-old son, already buckled into his car seat. These days, I always sit beside him. To make sure he’s OK. To help me be OK.
He fusses. I ask my husband to pass his bottle from the front. It’s a long drive home. Best he has some milk now. Maybe then he’ll nap. I tilt the bottle against his lips. He begins to suckle.
Until—
“ACK-HAUGHK, ACK-HAUGHK.”
His tiny body jolts. His fair skin flushes red, his eyes squeeze shut. I swear I see a tinge of blue in his bottom lip.
And just like that, the sandstorm arrives. Again. The car is gone. My husband. The lighthouse. Gone. I’m standing in the desert, alone, like a statue. Sand swirls around me, swallowing everything except a narrow tunnel through which I can see only my son and every terrible possibility unfolding.
I’m standing at a hospital bedside. My eyes scan the monitor, the drips, the ventilator settings. Always two steps ahead. I look down at the patient, and instead of a stranger’s baby, it’s mine. His eyes are lost in the sedation coursing through his veins. A plastic tube breathes for him.
All because I fed him a bottle in his car seat.
“Jenna, relax. He’s fine. It just went down the wrong pipe,” my husband says. My blood boils. I don’t know what I’ve been saying aloud since the sandstorm rolled in. But he’s a doctor. He should know about the risk of aspiration pneumonia. I tell him about a patient who aspirated a hamburger. How I spent the following week suctioning brown chunks of meat from his infected lungs. He tells me it was just breast milk. That he’ll be OK.
Will he? Can somebody promise me that on their life? On mine? On the precious beat of this tiny heart I am now responsible for?
I am desperate for someone to guarantee me the milk won’t descend to his lungs. That he will wake up in the morning. And that this newborn bubble won’t tragically burst.
My husband offered me that reassurance often. I craved it, yet couldn’t accept the certainty with which he gave it. I knew, perhaps better than most, that nobody could make these promises. So I appointed myself the keeper of every possibility.
It was a role I was, in many ways, exceptionally qualified for. I’d spent years working in pediatric critical care, where anticipating catastrophe was the job description. Where knowing what could happen next was sometimes the difference between life and death.
During my master’s program to become a family nurse practitioner, I’d chosen to study perinatal mood and anxiety disorders for my thesis project. I was two years shy of motherhood, but I’d been curious about the maternal brain since I was a young girl, watching my own mother raise four daughters and wither at times, too. I wonder how often she found herself in the desert.
I’d searched and synthesized and unraveled the literature. Postpartum depression, anxiety, obsessive-compulsive disorder. The effects of yoga on pregnant and postpartum mothers. Heck, I’d even become a certified yoga teacher myself. There I was, cradling the perfect resume to become a mother in my arms. Quietly, and rather arrogantly, I suppose I expected all of this to help me waltz through postpartum with just a few weeks’ worth of oversized pads and mostly, relative ease.
I understood the drastic estrogen and progesterone withdrawal after birth. The neurological adaptations that heighten sensitivity to potential threats. The way sleep deprivation amplifies anxiety.
What I hadn’t considered was what all that knowledge might become when the baby was mine. When there was no distinction between the patient and the person I loved most in the world. When I was the mother sitting atop the crinkled paper-lined table, afraid to confess the thoughts that ransacked my mind, knowing they might become words in a medical record.
Gone were the days of retreating into the reassuring distance of clinical objectivity. The science, terminology, and years at the bedside caring for critically ill children became the very language through which my anxiety spoke. My experience gave the intrusive thoughts a library of images to borrow from. I didn’t have to invent the worst-case scenarios. I’d witnessed them.
The sandstorms weren’t confined to the back seat of our car. They followed me home.
Into the quiet of our bedroom, where I’d zoom in on the baby monitor until I could make out the rise and fall of his chest. Up. Down. There he was. Breathing. I’d put the monitor down until the next alarm sounded somewhere inside my head.
They accompanied me into the moments someone else held him, when I was supposed to enjoy having my arms free, but instead found myself calculating the precise distance between us. They invited themselves into the ordinary, beautiful moments with my newborn that I still grieve. Moments I was physically present for, but mentally somewhere in the wreckage of a tragedy that hadn’t happened.
I had spent years learning about the maternal brain from the outside.
Now I was living inside one.
The months passed. My hormones began to settle. The intrusive thoughts spaced out their visits, and I began to recognize them for what they were.
Not premonitions. Not some sacred maternal intuition.
Thoughts.
Still frightening. Still unwelcome. But thoughts nonetheless.
I can’t tell you exactly when that shift began. I remember leaving my son with my husband for thirty hours to attend my best friend’s bachelorette party at six months postpartum. Thirty hours. An eternity for the self-appointed keeper of every possibility to leave her post.
The fear came with me. I went anyway. And for the first time in months, I remembered that I existed beyond it. It felt like drawing a line in the sand. It was an unfamiliar kind of progress. One I couldn’t measure, diagnose, or prescribe.
I’d spent years learning to recognize suffering in others. To assess it. Name it. Treat it. I could have written a convincing care plan for a mother enduring exactly what I was. But instead of looking at her from across an examination table, I was her.
A mother.
With sand in her eyes.
I still know what can happen to a child. I still carry the images of the children I cared for long before I had my own. I haven’t forgotten the medicine, and I don’t suppose I ever will. Sometimes I still find myself looking for the rise and fall of his chest.
And sometimes, I simply let him sleep.


